IPsec: an outdated technology for modern businesses?

Résumez ou partagez cet article :

In the world of SASE and SD-WAN, major American players such as Fortinet, Palo Alto and Cato Networks present themselves as cutting-edge innovators. Yet behind the marketing talk, a technology more than 25 years old is still used extensively in their solutions: IPsec. This protocol, originally created in the 1990s to connect two datacentres over the Internet, was not designed for the cloud, gigabit fibre or today’s hybrid working.

IPsec now suffers from structural limitations.

Its performance often caps out at between 300 and 600 Mb/s on standard devices, far below the capacity of FTTH or FTTO fibre, which reaches 1 to 5 Gb/s in France. It requires complex configuration (IKEv2, MTU management, NAT-T), adds latency due to encapsulation and offers poor resilience: at the slightest outage, the connection has to be renegotiated, sometimes resulting in user session loss. It is a robust technology… but slow, heavy and ill-suited to today’s needs.

Worse still: IPsec becomes a bottleneck when security features are enabled.

With Fortinet, Cato Networks or Palo Alto, throughput drops dramatically as soon as advanced encryption, DLP, SSL inspection or IPS are enabled. Some appliances fall below 200 Mb/s, even though businesses are paying for 1 Gb/s fibre. The result: security technology throttles network performance.

By contrast, modern protocols such as WireGuard, natively built into the WANUP solution, offer an alternative better suited to today’s needs. WireGuard uses modern algorithms (ChaCha20, Curve25519), can be configured in just a few lines and easily reaches 1 to 2 Gb/s on a standard CPU. Reconnection is instant, and the protocol is lightweight, Zero Trust compatible and ideal for cloud and hybrid environments.

Conclusion

IPsec is not “bad”, but it belongs to another era. Continuing to build modern architectures on it means accepting throttled fibre, needless latency and more complex infrastructure. In France, where connectivity is among the best-performing in Europe, businesses need an SD-WAN designed for their reality — not a technology inherited from the 1990s. WANUP has made this choice by adopting WireGuard and breaking away from the inertia of IPsec.